This article reflects its original publication date. Screening requirements and pricing may change; contact our team for current details.
Compliance isn’t just about avoiding legal issues. It’s about running the hiring process in a way that respects every applicant’s rights.
Employers and Institutions must follow laws when conducting background checks. These protect the interests and safety of both parties.
In this article, we’ll discuss background check compliance and offer some tips to ensure legal compliance for the one who initiated the verifications.
What Is Background Check Compliance?
Background check compliance means following federal laws, such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidelines. It also includes adhering to state and local regulations during background checks.
This federal law outlines how employers can legally conduct background screening. For instance, the FCRA requires employers to get written consent from applicants before a background check.
It also requires clear disclosures about how background reports will be used. Employers must provide applicants with a pre-adverse action notice and a copy of the background check report.
They must also include a summary of the applicant’s rights. If adverse action is considered, the employer must give the applicant time to review and dispute the report.
Only after this can they issue a final adverse action notice. These steps play an important role in staying compliant and protecting applicants’ rights.
Why Do You Need Background Check Companies?
Hiring the right candidate involves more than reviewing resumes and conducting interviews.
Employers must verify the information applicants provide and assess any potential risks, which often includes background checks.
Professional background check companies offer specialized services to help employers conduct thorough and compliant checks. Here’s why using a background check company is important:
Expert Access to Extensive Data Sources
Background check companies have access to a wide network of databases and resources often unavailable to individual businesses. Additionally, they provide access to global data for international screenings.
For businesses hiring across different regions or industries, this level of access is important in making sure that they have all the relevant details on a candidate.
Saving Time and Resources
Conducting thorough background checks internally can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.
Background check companies handle this process efficiently using advanced technology and databases to quickly collect accurate information.
Employers can focus on other aspects of the hiring process while receiving reliable results without delays by outsourcing to these companies.
Reducing Hiring Risks
Hiring the wrong candidate can lead to negligent hiring claims or workplace incidents.
Background check companies help employers better understand an applicant’s criminal record, employment history, and other relevant factors, allowing them to make informed decisions.
Providing Accurate Information
Incomplete or inaccurate background checks can lead to poor hiring decisions. Background check companies access comprehensive data sources, reducing the chances of errors or omissions.
This helps businesses make informed decisions based on accurate and complete information. This will protect both the company and the applicant.
Avoiding Internal Bias
Another key advantage of using background check companies is the reduction of internal bias during the hiring process.
Relying on an external, objective third party to conduct screenings helps businesses create a more transparent hiring process.
Background check companies provide factual, unbiased data about each candidate. This helps employers make decisions based solely on qualifications and background.
Access to Continuous Monitoring
Some background check companies offer continuous monitoring services. They update employers about any changes to an employee’s legal or criminal status after they’ve been hired.
This is particularly useful when employees have access to sensitive data, financial records, or vulnerable populations.
5 Background Check Providers to Keep Your Business Compliant
Picking the right background check company is key to staying compliant and making confident hiring decisions.
Here’s a list of top providers offering trustworthy and cost-effective screening services.
1. Stellar Background Checks
Stellar Background Checks offers a variety of screening services. These include criminal background checks, employment and education verifications, drug screenings, and social media checks.
We provide international background checks for global businesses. Our tools search hundreds of databases with just one click. Results are fast—usually within one to three days.
You can choose pay-as-you-go options or monthly invoicing with no contracts or hidden fees. Plus, our pricing is 15-30% lower than many competitors.
Pros: Fast results, customizable packages, international screenings, competitive pricing.
We offer five distinct packages to fit a variety of screening needs:
- Standard Package ($35): Includes SSN trace, criminal searches, and basic checks
- Bronze Package ($54): Adds education and employment verification to the Standard package
- Silver Package ($99): Includes a 10-panel drug test
- Gold Package ($104): Expands with driving history and financial background checks
- Platinum Package ($119): Offers complete coverage, including federal criminal search
We also offer a pay-as-you-go model without long-term contracts. Our user-friendly client portal even lets you monitor background check results as they are processed.
Fill out this form to connect with top talent through Stellar Background Checks.
2. Checkr
Source: Checkr
Checkr uses advanced technology to deliver fast background checks. Their services include criminal record searches, employment and education verifications, and drug screenings.
The automated platform integrates with HR systems, making it great for high-volume screening. Adjudication tools provide context on criminal records, helping employers make informed decisions.
Checkr has flexible pricing with three main tiers:
- Basic+ (starting from $29.99 per check): Includes SSN trace, sex offender registry, global watchlist, and national criminal record search. An optional county criminal search is available for an additional $15.
- Essential (starting from $54.99 per check): Adds a county criminal search to the standard checks, allowing for a more in-depth review.
- Professional (starting from $79.99 per check): Includes education and employment verification, suitable for roles needing additional background detail.
3. HireRight
Source: HireRight
HireRight provides background check services designed for international hiring needs. It offers global reach and compliance with local regulations. Custom pricing is available based on selected services and volume requirements.
HireRight offers several packages:
- Instant Criminal+ ($36.47): Covers criminal record checks, sex offender registry searches, and SSN validation. County-level searches are not included.
- Instant Criminal+ Local County ($54.95): Includes one county-level search in addition to the checks in Instant Criminal+. Results typically arrive within one to three days.
- Instant Criminal+ All Counties ($76.95): Includes multiple county-level searches, criminal record checks, sex offender registry searches, and SSN validation, with results delivered in one to three days.
4. GoodHire
Source: GoodHire
GoodHire offers transparent pricing and customizable background check packages. These include criminal checks, drug testing, and reference verifications.
The platform provides an applicant portal for candidates to view and dispute reports. This makes the hiring process open and fair.
It’s a great choice for small to mid-sized businesses needing simple background check solutions.
GoodHire’s packages include:
- Basic+ (starting at $29.99 per check): Includes SSN trace, sex offender registry search, global watchlist records, and national criminal records.
- Essential (starting at $54.99 per check): Expands on the Basic+ package with unlimited county criminal searches.
- Professional (starting at $79.99 per check): Adds education verification and employment history checks to the Essential package.
5. Veremark
Source: Veremark
Veremark provides background check packages to suit different hiring requirements. Packages range from basic identity checks to comprehensive screenings, catering to entry-level positions, mid-level professionals, and senior executives.
Veremark’s packages include:
- Essential Package ($24 per candidate): Covers basic identity checks and reference checks, suitable for entry-level or standard hires.
- Professional Package ($142 per candidate): Includes employment verification (covering the past 3 years), basic criminal checks, and social media screening for a more detailed review.
- Executive Package ($303 per candidate): Designed for senior-level hires, this package includes employment verification (covering the past five years), unlimited criminal checks, drug testing, and global sanctions checks.
Key Components of a Background Check
A background check consists of several key components that provide employers with information about a candidate’s history and suitability for a role.
These checks help employers assess risk and make better hiring decisions. Below are the most common elements included in a standard background check:
Criminal Record Check
A criminal background check looks into an individual’s history of arrests, convictions, and legal infractions. This includes checking databases for federal and local (such as county) criminal records.
Employment Verification
Employment verification confirms a candidate’s work history by contacting previous employers. This process involves checking for previous job descriptions and reasons for leaving. It’s a glimpse of a candidate’s past professional experience and qualifications.
Education Verification
This part of the background check process involves confirming the educational qualifications claimed by the candidate, such as diplomas and certifications. The providers will usually contact school officials and certification bodies to complete education verification.
Credit Report
These reports are used in positions that involve financial management such as handling vast amounts of money. An applicant’s credit history and debt are thoroughly analyzed to see potential patterns that may jeopardize the interest of the initiator.
Driving Record Check
For roles where driving is a requirement, employers may request a driving record check. These reports include information such as traffic violations and valid license statuses.
Social Media Screening
Employers may review publicly available information on a candidate’s social media accounts. Social media screening provides insights into an applicant’s character and suitability.
However, employers must approach social media screening carefully to avoid discrimination claims.
Drug Testing
Drug testing is a standard and mandatory in most states. These identify candidates who may use illegal substances that could have an impact on job performance or safety.
Professional License and Certification Verification
For certain professions, employers must verify the validity of licenses or certifications that the candidate claims to hold. A must in healthcare and engineering professions.
Reference Checks
Reference checks involve contacting individuals who can speak to a candidate’s skills, experience, and character.
Employers use reference checks to gain additional insight into a candidate’s work ethic, teamwork skills, and reliability.
International Background Checks
International background checks may be conducted for candidates who have lived or worked abroad.
These checks look into criminal records, employment history, education, and other relevant information from foreign countries.
Who Can Conduct a Background Check?
Various entities use background checks, which can be conducted on individuals for different purposes. Below are some common situations where background checks are required:
Employers
Private employers, government agencies, and non-profit organizations frequently request background checks as part of the hiring process.
These checks help employers verify a candidate’s criminal history, employment record, education, and other relevant details.
Landlords and Property Managers
Background checks are common in the housing industry. Landlords or property managers may request background checks on potential tenants.
These screenings usually focus on criminal records, as they help landlords determine whether a tenant may pose a risk to the property or other tenants.
Financial Institutions
Financial institutions, such as banks and credit unions, often require background checks before opening accounts, issuing loans, or offering credit as standard operating procedure.
Educational Institutions
Colleges and universities may conduct background checks on students or applicants, particularly for programs that involve placements in healthcare or other environments requiring close contact with vulnerable populations such as the elderly.
Volunteer Organizations
Volunteer groups, like those involving children or vulnerable individuals, often need background checks. For safety reasons, volunteers are thoroughly checked for criminal histories.
Professional Licensing Bodies
Certain industries, such as healthcare, law, finance, and education, require background checks for professional licensing.
Government and Security Clearances
Individuals applying for government positions, especially those involving national security, undergo thorough background checks.
These checks assess a person’s criminal history, financial standing, and personal connections to determine whether they pose a risk to national security.
Federal Laws and Regulations Governing Background Check Compliance
Federal laws establish how employers conduct background checks, focusing on protecting job applicants’ rights and maintaining transparency in the hiring process.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act
The employer or the consumer reporting agency must obtain explicit written consent from applicants before conducting background checks, explaining what information will be collected and its intended use.
A separate written disclosure must inform applicants that a background check will be conducted.
Suppose a background report leads to an adverse employment decision. In that case, employers must provide a pre-adverse action notice, allowing applicants to dispute inaccuracies, followed by a final adverse action notice if the decision is upheld.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Guidelines
The EEOC is strict against employment discrimination. It can be discrimination based on race, national origin, sex, and more.
Employers must avoid practices that disproportionately impact any of these protected groups.
The EEOC recommends an individualized assessment for applicants with criminal records. It evaluates the nature of the crime and its relevance to the job.
Blanket policies that disqualify applicants with criminal records are discouraged as they may result in discrimination claims.
Ban-the-Box Laws and State Regulations
Ban-the-box laws delay inquiries into an applicant’s criminal history until later in the hiring process. These laws help reduce bias and give applicants a fair chance to be evaluated on their qualifications.
States also impose their regulations, such as limits on using credit reports or specific rules for retaining background check records.
In California, the Fair Chance Act requires employers to wait until after a conditional job offer before asking about criminal convictions.
Employers must comply with both federal and state laws, often adhering to the stricter regulation when conflicts arise.
Why Is Compliance in Background Checks Important?
Compliance with background check regulations benefits business owners, from legal protection to building a strong company reputation.
Legal Protection
Federal and state laws set strict guidelines for conducting background checks. Adhering to these regulations protects employers from potential lawsuits and fines.
For example, using a criminal background report without following the proper legal process can result in employment discrimination claims.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires businesses to notify candidates before conducting background checks and to obtain their written consent.
If an employer decides not to hire someone based on the results, they must give candidates a copy of the report and time to address any inaccuracies.
Fairness in Hiring
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission stresses the importance of fairness when evaluating candidates with a criminal record.
Employers must assess each candidate individually, taking into account the nature of the offense, how much time has passed since the incident, and whether the offense is relevant to the job.
This process allows for more informed hiring decisions and helps avoid discriminatory practices.
Fair assessments also give qualified candidates a better opportunity to be considered based on their current qualifications rather than being unfairly judged for past offenses.
Reputation Management
Compliance with hiring regulations shows a company’s commitment to fair practices, which can improve its reputation.
Businesses that follow these rules demonstrate respect for legal standards and build trust with potential employees.
This attracts a broader pool of candidates and strengthens relationships with clients and partners.
Companies known for fair and legal hiring practices are more likely to attract top talent, which benefits the business in the long run.
Proper Handling of Adverse Actions
When a business decides not to hire a candidate based on a background check, it must follow the legal steps outlined for adverse actions.
This process starts with sending the candidate a pre-adverse action letter, which includes a copy of the background report and explains the intent to take a negative hiring action.
The candidate has the right to review and dispute the findings before making a final decision.
If the decision remains unchanged, the employer must send a final adverse action notice.
Following these steps allows candidates to address any errors in the report and keeps the hiring process transparent and fair.
What Makes Stellar Background Checks Stand Out
Stellar Background Checks offers a comprehensive screening service that excels in several areas, making it an ideal partner for employers seeking thorough background checks.
Here’s what sets Stellar Background Checks apart:
Strong Compliance Knowledge
Stellar Background Checks follows all necessary legal frameworks, including the Fair Credit Reporting Act and applicable state laws.
Stellar’s focus on compliance helps employers avoid legal pitfalls, giving them peace of mind when handling background screenings.
Stellar understands the regulations governing different industries, allowing services to be suited and meet specific legal requirements.
Wide Range of Screening Services
Stellar Background Checks provides an extensive suite of services to cover all aspects of the hiring process.
For businesses that operate internationally, Stellar also offers global background checks, making it a flexible and reliable choice across various industries and geographies.
Fast and Accurate Results
Time matters when it comes to hiring, and Stellar Background Checks delivers reports typically within one to three days.
Despite the quick turnaround, they maintain high accuracy standards, with trained professionals verifying each report to avoid errors.
Stellar’s ability to balance speed and precision helps employers make timely and informed hiring decisions.
Affordable and Transparent Pricing
Stellar offers cost-effective solutions, often saving businesses 15-30% compared to other providers. This affordability does not come at the expense of quality. With transparent pricing and no hidden fees, employers get reliable screening services that fit within their budget.
Award-Winning Customer Support
Stellar Background Checks prides itself on providing top-notch customer service. With a support team available to assist with any issues, Stellar maintains strong relationships with clients, contributing to a high client retention rate.
The dedication to support sets Stellar Background Checks apart from competitors, offering employers guidance throughout the screening process.
Verify With Stellar Background Checks
Stellar Background Checks helps companies make the winning hire with our comprehensive background check services.
We prioritize speed, accuracy, and compliance when generating background check reports to ensure you make confident hiring decisions.
Onboard top-tier talent quickly by filling out this form or contacting us at 1-800-301-4140.
FAQs About Background Check Compliance
What does “in compliance” mean for a background check?
“In compliance” means conducting background checks according to federal laws like the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), state and local laws, and EEOC guidelines. It ensures legal and fair practices during the screening process.
What does managed state compliance mean by a background check?
Managed state compliance refers to adhering to specific state laws regulating background checks. This includes requirements like ban-the-box laws or restrictions on using criminal records and credit reports during hiring.
What is an FCRA-compliant background check?
An FCRA-compliant background check follows the guidelines of the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Employers must obtain written consent, provide disclosures, and issue pre-adverse and final adverse action notices if adverse employment decisions are made.
What makes you not pass a background check?
Failing a background check may occur due to criminal records, discrepancies in employment history, or negative credit reports. Employers must follow compliance laws, ensuring fair evaluations based on job-related factors.
